Compare Villas, Resorts, & Rentals in Shelter Island, New York, USA
About Casai's Private Villas and Holiday Rentals in Shelter Island
Discover more than 146 vacation rentals available in Shelter Island. These rentals, ranging from vacation rentals to Casai Homes and other short-term private accommodations, offer top-notch amenities with unbeatable value, ensuring both comfort and luxury. Enjoy more space and value when you stay at a Casai property in Shelter Island.
Seeking last-minute deals or the best available offers for cottages, condos, private villas, and spacious vacation homes? With Casai in Shelter Island, you can effortlessly compare various deals with just a click. Whether you're looking for a Casai with exceptional swimming pools, hot tubs, pet-friendly options, or large master suite bedrooms equipped with large screen televisions, you'll find a variety of options near Shelter Island. On average, places to stay near Shelter Island offer 909.39 ft², with nightly prices averaging CA $1,443.
With Casai, finding and comparing holiday rentals in Shelter Island is easy and secure, often at a 30-40% discount compared to hotel prices. Simply search for your destination and secure your reservation today.
Other Places to Stay in Shelter Island, NY
Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island?
What are the top holiday rentals in Shelter Island?
- Peaceful and Private Shelter Island Getaway
- Work and Play Special! Extended Stay Discount
- Farmhouse Nestled by Meadow, Pool, Near Beaches and Centrally Located!
- Private oasis with new baths and heated Gunite pool near Wades Beach
- Tranquility Base; Architect-Renovated, Modern Ranch With Heated Pool
- Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach
- Lovely home by the sea with dock and heated Gunite pool!
- Shelter Island Sun Filled Modern Waterfront Home with Dock
- Contemporary Home with heated pool and waterviews on Shelter Island
- Bright, open waterfront house with gorgeous sunsets and private beach
How many Casai.ca holiday rentals are available in Shelter Island?
As of 2025, Casai boasts over 146 properties listed in the Shelter Island area, with more being added continually. By consolidating listings from various websites, Casai provides an extensive selection of the finest Casai properties in Shelter Island.
Nearby Neighborhood (5)
| Neighborhood | Property Count |
|---|---|
| The Heights Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 419 |
| Menantic Creek Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 213 |
| Coecles Harbor Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 293 |
| Shorewood Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 182 |
| Montclair Colony Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 197 |
